How to Choose the Best Replacement Front Door: A Comprehensive Guide

1. Introduction

Given the importance of the impression that the front door makes, when renovating their homes most homeowners choose to replace front doors, rather than any other doors. The fact that they can be stylishly designed and can have unique features like glass or sophisticated materials only bolsters the desire to replace the front door of a house. However, selecting a new front door for the house isn’t just about aesthetic preference and picking a more or less pretty looking unit, as there are several factors that need to be considered in order to make the right choice. To help you decide, here is a guide on the main types of front doors and what to look out for when choosing among them, so that you make sure you pick the best door that will meet your looking for.

We often hear that the first impression is the strongest. Indeed, it is hard to argue with this when we are invited to somebody’s home and their old front door greets us with its worn paint, sad state, and creaky hinges. Don’t forget that this part of the house is also the same front line defense you have from any kind of disaster that might come your way.

1.1. Significance of Front Doors

Thus, the manner in which the door looks represents the personality of the owner – dependable, stylish, confident, and welcoming. Suppose it is time for you to replace your front door. Changing your front door can be a smart investment because a front door replacement can return 69.3% of its value upon the resale of your home. There are plenty of replacement front door choices to choose from but to help you in getting started in the decision-making process, here’s a quick guide on how to choose the best replacement front door for your home.

When it comes to upgrading, renovating, or redesigning our houses, most of the time, homeowners seem to overlook the front door. Many of us tend to take our front door for granted, when in fact, it should be given more importance. Fact: Did you know that the front door is the most often used house part? A study says that homeowners open and close their front door 4-6 times a day. And in a year, 98 percent of air drafts in their house comes from the front door. That is why it is important to keep your front door in shape and well-maintained. But did you know that front doors also act as a home’s centerpiece? They act as a house’s focal point and are also considered head turners when homeowners have visitors in their home. Remember, being a house’s facade, the first thing that guests notice is your front door.

2. Understanding Your Needs

Appearance: Alongside functionality, you will want to consider the visual appeal of your replacement front door. Make sure that the door is in keeping with the style and period of your property. Residential front doors are available in many different designs and styles, with a variety of glass styles and materials available. It is a good idea to select a finish that compliments the rest of your frontage, while also being sure that your use of color will not restrict your future options.

Durability: Your replacement front door also needs to be well-made and last, whatever the weather. Look for doors that warranty against rusting, peeling, and warping. Inspect the hardware used to mount the door – it should be tough and weatherproof. Wood, steel, and fiberglass all make good surface materials for a replacement door. The best material for you will depend on your specific needs.

Security: One of your first considerations should be security. However good a replacement door may look, it will not be considered a satisfactory purchase if it does not do the job of keeping you and your home safe. In order to choose the correct door, you will need to think about the strength of the material it is made from, plus whether the door is double-glazed and if it has a secure locking system.

Before you make a final decision on a replacement front door, it is a good idea to take a close look at what is available and to understand your own specific requirements.

2.1. Security Considerations

NOTE: Although wooden doors are more scratch-resistant when compared to single metal doors, metal doors with a wooden finish might provide a better security level.

– Material Strength. Wooden doors are known to be thicker compared to other door materials (e.g., fiberglass), which is the main reason for their higher strength. Thus, they are also relatively more resistant to kicks and scratches compared to other door types. – Door Locks. The locks for wooden doors are available in various form factors and security features, which gives you a higher flexibility in choosing the lock type you want for your house. Plus, most of them work well with modern home security systems. – Door Hinges. As a rule, wooden doors come with more reliable hinges, which are usually mounted in the frame deep enough to provide better breaking resistance. – Stability. Weather conditions usually have a much lower impact on metal and wooden doors compared to their fiberglass counterparts. However, wood can still be exposed to relatively high humidity, especially if your house does not have proper ventilation.

A rapidly growing number of homeowners now consider wooden front doors for their house security. And they are right, as these doors offer a great combination of security and style.

2.2. Aesthetic Preferences

Some homeowner associations, specifically in historic neighborhoods, regulate nearly every aspect of a home’s architectural features, its aesthetic appeal, maintaining and preserving high property values, and the quality of life for all its community members. Whether or not you live in such a neighborhood, consider your home’s current and/or new color palette to blend with the colors and textures used on your façade and landscaping visible from the street. Other design elements homes with great curb appeal use are contemporary, transitional, or traditional design features that match the theme established and emphasized by other architectural details.

Aesthetic preferences are personal; what one person likes, another may not. That being said, there are some important influences to keep in mind. Since a buyer is likely to make well-thought out color choices and other features to create curb appeal for their home, a basic entry door package often includes a formulaic design with a prefinished painted or stained exterior. Since the majority of residential front doors, not including sidelites or transoms, are in the 6’8″ height family, wider than standard doors make the entry approachable to people of all abilities and can enhance a home’s timeless appeal.

3. Types of Front Doors

Upgrades for front entry doors typically include stained glass, metal cable finishes like wrought iron, brass and copper, with additional fasteners and sidelights. Fiberglass, steel doors or wood doors and even composite doors can unite one or two of these things together in a durable, energy efficient door. Fiberglass is known for its excellent insulation value and durability, while energy-efficient steel front doors are generally less costly than wood doors, even though wooden doors require less maintenance and have a beautiful wooden finish. Steel doors generally have a shorter warranty but reduce the cost initially by using it when installing, and it’s the safest of the three choices.

Front Entry Doors: These are the most common front doors and they are called front entry doors because they are located at the main entryway of the house. Front entry doors can have many different architectural styles and decorative treatments. Since they generally have to be safe and keep out the pesky elements, heavy duty, durable front entry doors are very popular, but they are also available in upscale versions made of more aesthetically pleasing materials.

3.1. Wooden Doors

A downside associated with wooden front doors is their propensity to rot after long periods of exposure to high levels of humidity and wetness. This is why finishing a wooden door, either with sealant, paint, or stain, is an essential step that no homeowner should ignore. Front doors made using this material can drop into any price range. The cheapest varieties of wooden front doors available on the market come in at $200-$300, while the most expensive wooden units being sold are priced around $4,000. These prices do not include the upfront costs associated with the aforementioned finish.

Wooden front doors have served as the standard in the front door market for thousands of years. These doors are known for their beauty, ability to tolerate a wide variety of finishes, and very competent strength. Importantly, modifying a wooden entry door is an easy task that can be accomplished by any homeowner. This type of door can be made using a wide variety of wooden materials. Common materials used to produce wooden front doors are: Basswood, Douglas Fir, Mahogany, Pine, Red Oak, and White Oak. Each of these woods has unique properties and can significantly impact the price of the unit.

3.2. Fiberglass Doors

It is the most preferred door in the USA market. 51% of the market for entrance doors is related to steel doors. The option has too many different colors. Superficial scratches can be fixed right away. However, it cannot be repaired if the skin or substructure is hit. It deteriorates because of the scratches. Surface moisture may have an adverse effect. They also insulate better. Some steel doors have coatings that make them look like real wood. Because they are already installation-ready, professionals find them easier to work with. Keep in mind that steel doors can show patterns and surface images and can be affected by dimension changes in hot or cold conditions. There are only a few dents that can be filled if not treated correctly. It is broad, but a wooden door cannot be too heavy.

Fiberglass doors are a combination of steel and wooden doors. They give an excellent stylish look and high insulation. In addition, they are relatively cheaper than wooden doors and require less maintenance compared to steel doors. Finally, they are resistant to water and may get stuck but do not rot. They are also resistant to scratches from animals or kids and have finished wood graining on them. However, some people do not prefer them because they may be misleading. Unlike real wood, they resist certain staining or finishing methods. But the cost and benefits they provide, including low maintenance, are valued in this conventional price range with this method.

3.3. Steel Doors

Also featured at are security storm entrance doors by ProVia. One thing to consider with steel entry doors is their weight. It’s not just the weight of the door. Add to that the serving of a glass and the weight of the frame, plus the weight of decorative hardware. That’s a lot of heft to contend with throughout the lifecycle of the door.

Quality steel entry doors must be rated for forced entry, but style is not neglected. named two steel doors among its top ten front doors. received two nods in this list. One of these was the ProVia Legacy Steel Entry system which comes as a door only or with sidelights, an arched top, and a double door option. The 20-ga steel comes with a non-removable pin for added security. The exclusion of a wooden frame surrounding the door eliminates transference of temperature from one side to the other, thereby enhancing the benefits of a polyurethane “Therma-tru” core.

4. Key Features to Consider

Durability in any environmental condition, whether it be direct sunlight, extreme cold, hurricanes, fire, or salt air. Look for exterior doors made of fiberglass, which is resistant to adding heavy impressions from wear and tear when compared to the medium or low-density ones. Also, look for doors treated with protective coatings like UV-stable finishes, factory finishes, and Gel Stain or a stabilized seal. The most popular for front doors are paint-grade, stain-grade, veneer, and designer finishes. When talking about the door’s overall performance, we should mention the door installation. It’s recommended to hire a professional installer, even if you are dealing with a pre-hung door. The door must be installed according to the manufacturer’s instructions to uphold the seal of all warranties.

In addition, you need to make sure that a new door meets your security requirements: it must be strong, have durable hardware, and be impenetrable. And don’t forget about thermal insulation. If you need to increase it, choose a door with a low U-value, as this is calculated based on the thermal conductivity of door insulation and tells you how well the doors prevent hot or cold air from traveling inside or outside, which can improve your overall energy efficiency.

4.1. Material Strength

In regard to material safety, heavier options such as solid wood or hard metals (though extremely durable) do not rate as highly as fiberglass in terms of securing your home or structures. Fiberglass doors have a foam interior, adding to the energy efficiency while offering greater security. Wood and steel doors with a foam core can help by reinforcing the door structure, but these methods may be more expensive, making them less practical than fiberglass. Granted the reality that we do want to offer you solid options, like wood and steel, despite the fact that we give a slightly higher nod to the strengthened versions of both of these.

Not only that, but the material must be able to withstand impact without being damaged. This type of instability can frequently lead to greater vulnerability in your property. To avoid this, choose materials that will not become vulnerable to damage when faced with challenges ranging from the weather to a potential intruder. When a door becomes damaged, it presents a number of safety issues you want to avoid. This is one of the reasons why material strength is considered an important variable that should not be taken lightly. Just as important as any other feature the door must have.

4.2. Energy Efficiency

The most important thing about checking the efficiency of a model is the energy assessment. The R-value rates the insulation factor in the front door. For example, a wooden model with a foam core will have a thicker center, so the R-value will be higher. Fiberglass will be more likely to have one. Polyurethane insulation instead of polystyrene is another connection, polystyrene. But remember that it is not only the insulation layer that counts. Whether the door is installed correctly and whether heat loss occurs must also be verified. The high-energy efficiency doors have a complete seal to keep their interior warm and cool air dry.

Energy efficiency is another important aspect to consider when choosing a front door. A large outer surface means a lot of heat is lost. Also, the room itself can be colder if your front door is not well insulated. Manufacturers now offer energy-efficient gates with wooden or fiberglass inner frames. Some even carry an energy check sticker that estimates you can save both dollars and kilowatt-hour by installing a specific front door model. However, just because a gateway company advertises energy efficiency does not mean it does. To reduce heat loss, a front door must be well insulated. And insulation is an important criterion to judge front door models.

5. Installation and Maintenance

Do not forget to say that if you have done a little maintenance on the space before you order the door – for example, if you are renovating an old home on your own – then you should avoid any termite damage, auxiliary structure, or any other serious problems with the entrance of an unusual size. To prevent degradation of your roof structure or your house, always hire a professional for a house extension or repair beyond installation. In the case of metal or fiberglass doors, professional installation can also prevent potential inconsistencies in the interior. You must choose the best installation method according to your skills and experience. Keep in mind, however, that poorly installed door frames can be the source of considerable maintenance work. Always prioritize the installation of the door frame and the door.

Once you have determined what types of materials are best for your purposes, you can begin to consider how to get your door into place. Many people have encountered strange and eerie spaces in old houses and condos; the sizes of the door can change drastically. Do not worry! There are doors of almost all sizes that are available in the world. The problem will most likely be simple and affordable to solve. The wood doors, in particular, are incredibly simple and easy to fix for anyone. Other doors may require a special order to get in your house. In both of these cases, it is important to know the exact size of the door in question.

5.1. Professional Installation Benefits

When you come to a professional team with a good clientele and numerous projects, most likely you will be given a warranty period for the entire work. This warranty ensures all operations are done properly. In addition, a good seller often has contracts for the installation of doors with a professional team, which means you can see the work of the team with your own eyes when you choose your future door. Nevertheless, the installation of external doors is not a simple and quick process. If you decide on a professional installer, you must make sure you have all the details set up to ensure that the entire project runs smoothly and there is no cleaning work for you afterward.

If you decide to hire a professional for the installation, it would be more convenient but often costs more. You can, however, spend your time on other important tasks while your new front door is installed. Also, a professional installer has all the necessary knowledge and skills, so you can be sure that your front door is set up properly.

Eager to uncover more? Step inside and find out what makes us exceptional!

Top Questions to Ask Before Getting a Replacement Front Door


Lotz, W. A. “… systems in buildings, chilled water pipes and underground pipes: a guide for architects, engineers, contractors, facility managers, construction professionals ….” 2021. [HTML]

Werremeyer, K. “Understanding and Negotiating Construction Contracts: A Contractor’s and Subcontractor’s Guide to Protecting Company Assets.” 2023. [HTML]

Law, Tim. “Beyond minimum: Proposition for building surveyors to exceed the minimum standards of the construction code.” Journal of legal affairs and dispute resolution in engineering and construction 13.2 (2021): 03721001.

Kendall, S. H. “Residential Architecture as Infrastructure: Open Building in Practice.” 2021. [HTML]

Stevens, M. and Smolders, J. “Understanding Australian Construction Contractors: A Guide for Emerging Professionals.” 2022. [HTML]

Comiskey, D. and Wilson, K. “A Performance Barrier? Cavity Barrier Installation in Wall Envelope Makeups.” Management, 2020.

Vaz-Serra, P., Wasim, M., and Egglestone, S. “Design for manufacture and assembly: A case study for a prefabricated bathroom wet wall panel.” Journal of Building Engineering, 2021. [HTML]

Holm, L. and Schaufelberger, J. E. “Construction cost estimating.” 2021.

Ormiston, R., Belman, D., Brockman, J., and Hinkel, M. “Rebuilding residential construction.” 2020. [HTML]

VanDemark, Lance, Caroline M. Clevenger, and Matthew Click. “Building envelope issues within construction-defect litigation.” Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction 13.4 (2021): 03721003. [HTML]

No tags for this post.

Related Posts:




Don’t want to deal with high-pressure sales and misleading pricing games?

Neither do we! Call or email us for a different way to get a beautiful new front entry door.